I have already replaced all those bearings & bushings. Everything felt & looked tight. Could the pinion shaft itself be worn by thousandths and need replaced? However, the drive gear (gear starter nose sits in) did have a little play sitting in its position on the pinion shaft, (the inner part of the gear to the pinion shaft, not the teeth to the starter nose). The ring gear looked fine. The needle bearing on the solenoid side was completely trashed, so I replaced it. I did bite the bullet and replaced the entire starter at the same time I put in all new bearings and thrust washers. It sounds like I might need to replace the drive gear and the pinion gear and shaft.
By the way, I do want to repair it, not just fix it...that is why I am on here picking you guys brains. The guy I bought it from always took it back to the Harley dealer. Costing him alot of money. I twist my own bolts and buy my parts, I know what is getting done and what hasn't been done. I don't trust someone else to do my work for me. If you click on sporty_bitch there is a pic of my scoot at the bottom of the page. Check her out, let me know what you think.
Hey, thanks for all your help tmmobile. sporty_bitch